Category: Young Adult Fiction > Romance
Series: Sweet Dreams, #4
Setting: 1980s Michigan, USA
Locations: Mackinac Island, Petoskey
Key Words: Love triangle, class, family, snobbery, LARP, holiday, romance, cousin
In Brief: The biggest issue with this book is that we’re supposed to believe that Amy is torn between Pete and Guy when Guy is just plain awful. We’re told repeatedly that he’s really hot, and that’s why Amy can’t stay away despite him being a prat, but she finds Pete attractive too, so it doesn’t make any sense. The dialogue’s often clunky, too.
Huh?: The Chad-like Guy and all his super snobby friends apparently play a LARP version of D&D. Not likely.
Protagonist: Amy Painter (16 years old, female, white, American, middle class, slim, able-bodied, neurotypical)
Diverse Key Characters: Pete Demarest (working class)
Content Warning: Unhealthy weight loss discussion and behaviour. (Amy’s aunt and cousin diet constantly and want Amy to do the same. Initially she says she doesn’t need to, because she’s not overweight, but by the end of the book she’s crowing about her stomach shrinking and she’s dropped a dress size in three weeks.)
Author: Melinda Pollowitz (American)